What Shopify handles and what you still own
Shopify gives you good data. The judgment and filings are still yours.
- Shopify handles: checkout, order and payout reports, sales tax calculation (with Shopify Tax), and Form 1099-K for Shopify Payments when you pass the threshold.
- You still own: sales tax registration and filing in each state where you have nexus, recording gross sales and fees correctly, inventory and cost of goods sold, income tax returns, estimated tax payments, and the choice of entity.
Shopify is not a marketplace facilitator. On your own store you are the seller, so the sales tax rules in our e-commerce sales tax guide apply to you directly.
What a CPA does for a Shopify brand
- Payout reconciliation. We book gross sales, discounts, refunds, Shopify fees, chargebacks and reserves separately, then clear each payout to the bank. See Shopify payouts reconciliation.
- Inventory at landed cost. Supplier cost plus freight-in, duties, tariffs and brokerage, so gross margin is real. See tariffs, landed cost and COGS and inventory accounting.
- Sales tax nexus. We total sales by state from Shopify and your other channels and flag where you must register.
- 1099-K reconciliation. The form shows gross payments. We tie it to the sales on your return so the IRS sees why the numbers differ. See 1099-K for online sellers.
- Tax returns and planning. Schedule C, partnership or S corp returns, quarterly estimates, and whether an S corp election fits.
- Financial statements. Monthly reporting for you, and statements a bank or investor will accept when you need financing.
Signs it is time to bring in a CPA
- Your books show bank deposits as sales, so fees and refunds are missing.
- You buy inventory in bulk and expense it all when you pay the supplier.
- You import and are not sure whether tariffs belong in inventory.
- You ship to customers in many states and have never checked nexus.
- Your 1099-K is far higher than your profit and you do not know why.
- You owed a large tax bill last April that you did not plan for.
- A lender, investor or buyer has asked for financial statements.
Messy history is common. We can start with catch-up bookkeeping and move to monthly Shopify bookkeeping.
How it works with us
Best for: Shopify brands with inventory, multichannel sales or multi-state customers, from first-year stores to established DTC brands.
- Free initial consultation. Tell us your channels, apps, sourcing and what is not working in your books.
- Fees quoted upfront, in writing. Transparent, fair fees in an engagement letter before work starts.
- Setup review. We review your Shopify reports, connected apps, chart of accounts and inventory method.
- Clean books. Payout clearing, landed cost, and sales tax liability that ties to filings.
- Ongoing. Monthly reporting, quarterly tax planning and year-end returns.
For the full service, see E-commerce accounting services.
Shopify app vs bookkeeper vs CPA firm: who handles what
| Task | Shopify and accounting apps | Bookkeeper | CPA firm |
|---|---|---|---|
| Payout clearing (gross sales, fees, refunds, reserves) | Imports data; some apps post summary entries | Records and reconciles | Reviews and fixes the method |
| COGS and landed cost | Stores the unit cost you enter | Records purchases | Sets costing, tariff and freight treatment |
| Sales tax calculation | Yes (Shopify Tax) | No | Reviews setup |
| Sales tax nexus, registration and filing | Calculation and reports; filing is yours or a filing service’s | Sometimes files | Decides nexus, registers, files or reviews |
| 1099-K to books reconciliation | Provides the form | Sometimes | Yes |
| Income tax return | No | No | Yes |
| Tax planning and S corp decision | No | No | Yes |
| Financial statements for lenders | No | Internal reports | Yes, including reviews and audits |
Expert CPAs. Personal attention.
Shopify books not adding up? Bring your payout and order reports to a free initial consultation and talk to a CPA about your store.
Frequently asked questions
Sources
- Shopify Help Center: Tax reporting for Shopify Payments (Form 1099-K)
- Shopify Help Center: Shopify Tax
- Shopify Help Center: Shopify Payments payouts
- Shopify Help Center: Shopify Payments reserves
- IRS IR-2025-107: Form 1099-K threshold reverts to $20,000
- IRS Publication 334: Tax Guide for Small Business
- IRS Publication 538: Accounting Periods and Methods
General information as of October 18, 2026. Tax rules change; talk to a CPA about your situation.